Mryzyz wrote:'The true strength of a division is shown outside it's top 10.'
Errr... no.
And besides, the UFC doesn't have, arguably, any top 30 Featherweights outside their top ten.
% of top 5, % of top 10, % of top 25...
Whichever way you look at it, the UFC has less of a grip on the top Featherweight talent than they have on their other divisions. Even Heavyweight.
'If there aren't a lot of top 10 featherweights in the UFC it's because of the way the wins of other fighters stack up'
Errr... yeah.
Hioki, Bibiano, Takaya et al. all have better wins than all the UFC Featherweight contenders. Hence their perceived superiority. Your point being...?
Baffling claim.
The fact that the UFC has less top 10 featherweights than they have top 10 fighters in other divisions speaks to the global strength of the division.
There aren't tons of fighters outside the UFC who have looked dominant anyway. Omigawa, who was regarded as top 5, just got comprehensively beaten by Mendes who was floating around outside the top 10. The only real notables outside the UFC are Takaya, Sandro, Warren, Fernandes and Hioki.
Are Takaya's wins that good? He's beaten Hansen who's not proven at featherweight, and Bebe who doesn't have any relevant wins since 2007. Tokoro had Takaya in massive trouble, and as much as I love Tokoro, he's a bellow average featherweight. Fernandes is a good win, but his recent wins boil down to the same guys, Takaya himself, Hansen and a green Warren. Otsuka and Imanari aren't good featherweight wins. I'm not even convinced Takaya and Fernandes are comfortably top 10, I think they're borderline.
Sandro is quality, but the only actual names on his record are his debatable loss to Omigawa, his win over Kanehara and his loss to Hioki. His other wins were over untested prospects and average guys like Hata and Hoshino. His biggest win is really Kanehara, but Kanehara was gifted his way to the final of the Sengoku tournament, should have lost to Chan Sung Jun and Omigawa, just got stomped by Maeda who isn't really a featherweight.
Warren has good wins but Soto and Freire are his only good wins recently, and he was getting annihilated by both of them and shouldn't really have got the decision over Freire.
Hioki is legitimately very good, and number two in the world, shouldn't have lost to Omigawa.
So who are you putting in your top 5 if you're only ranking Aldo from the UFC? Who are these non-UFC featherweights outside the top 10 who make up the top 30?